GBS RIP

That appears to be the message from Dirk Niebel, Germany’s Development Cooperation Minister. General Budget Support is donor aid that goes straight to treasury without any earmarks to support the overall budget.

Niebel was in town to discuss German aid to Tanzania. He’s reportedly sceptical about GBS and wants more earmarked, project based aid for decentralisation, water, health and HIV and AIDS. Maybe Finance Minister Mkulo did a first rate job in convincing him of its benefits as German GBS  support will remain at existing levels. Or maybe Niebel is not comfortable in being a first mover in backing away from GBS, but wants to get some things off his chest anyway.

Mkulo was forthright in the assurances he gave:

Mr Mkulo said at a press conference that Tanzania will use every penny wisely and for the intended purpose, assuring that every single cent from the German taxpayers will be accounted for.

That’s ambitious, given that last year President Kikwete told us that 30 percent of the government budget is lost to corruption.

For a couple of years now, aid modalities have been getting a lot of play in the niche world of aid blogging. But any modality is bound to come a cropper when faced with such cognitive dissonance – on the part of both giver and receiver.

3 responses to “GBS RIP

  1. Retorics!
    What’s the word for that in Kiswahili?
    Nicely summed up, thanks!
    Pernille

  2. Maneno tu (just words). Au siasa (or politics)? I believe that’s the sentiment you were looking for in Kiswahili.

    And at the end of the day, through these actions the unpleasant task of unpacking ‘aid’ has been raised again: how, how much, to whom and for what? Tuambizane ukweli. Lets tell each other the truth.

    Microfinance is business: small scale, large returns. Why are we acting shocked? Just a couple of years ago, it was the new Solution To Poverty.

    Tuambizane ukweli.

    e.

  3. Pingback: Playing for the high one, Dancing with the devil, Going with the flow, It’s all a game to me « Swahili Street

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s